Model Airport Reviews - Anybody In?

[BubblesAviation]

I’m thinking about making a model airport review series like some other people have done on YouTube. But I want to be completely honest. I didn’t get as much tips as I wanted when my airport got reviewed (I had no feedback, which means my airport was good, and it’s going to the grand finale) and I want to fill that gap. If you want your airport reviewed on my YouTube channel (BubblesAviation) just DM me and I’ll give you the Google form. Thank you!

 

[OllieBHaas25]

The problem with review series for model airports is you can’t be too harsh because the people who submitted them actually watch the videos, unlike video game reviews. I had my airport reviewed on YouTube a few years ago and the guy didn’t say anything other than the name of my airport bc it looked like a 2 year old made it (I was still learning how to do all the markings and paint). Since then I’ve had 2 more airports reviewed and I still haven’t gotten good feedback despite them being 10x better than the previous one. That being said I will be submitting my next airport when it’s finished. Is there a set starting time that I need to be finished by?

 

[LeoMuse747]

The problem with review series for model airports is you can’t be too harsh because the people who submitted them actually watch the videos, unlike video game reviews. I had my airport reviewed on YouTube a few years ago and the guy didn’t say anything other than the name of my airport bc it looked like a 2 year old made it (I was still learning how to do all the markings and paint). Since then I’ve had 2 more airports reviewed and I still haven’t gotten good feedback despite them being 10x better than the previous one. That being said I will be submitting my next airport when it’s finished. Is there a set starting time that I need to be finished by?

Well, if you submit something for a review, you must be prepared for criticism... so basically the guy who reviewed was the one at fault.

 

[BubblesAviation]

The problem with review series for model airports is you can’t be too harsh because the people who submitted them actually watch the videos, unlike video game reviews. I had my airport reviewed on YouTube a few years ago and the guy didn’t say anything other than the name of my airport bc it looked like a 2 year old made it (I was still learning how to do all the markings and paint). Since then I’ve had 2 more airports reviewed and I still haven’t gotten good feedback despite them being 10x better than the previous one. That being said I will be submitting my next airport when it’s finished. Is there a set starting time that I need to be finished by?

im just seeing if anyone is interested. But I totally understand. I left a section where you can leave remarks about your airport.

 

[OllieBHaas25]

im just seeing if anyone is interested. But I totally understand. I left a section where you can leave remarks about your airport.

That’s perfect

 

[diecastfreak]

I wouldnt care about a strangers opinion.

 

[LeoMuse747]

Sent mine!

 

[Sithan400]

I wouldnt care about a strangers opinion.

With any type of review series, it really depends on who is/are the reviewer(s) to avoid bias and maintain objectivity. Perhaps calling on a panel of modelers with real modeling airport experience. An academy if you will, of moderators @LeoMuse747 or @YesterAirlines or people like Brian Keene, Hu Chow or Pasin Phadungcharoen.

Cheers, S

 

[bakejobb_23]

I wouldn’t mind being a voice of feedback/a “Judge”. I’m fairly active here and love seeing good model airports! Here are my credentials with what I’ve made/working on:

A generally finished Fictional layout:



WIP PHL:


Small Ramp Section:


Runway Section:

 

[BubblesAviation]

I wouldn’t mind being a voice of feedback/a “Judge”. I’m fairly active here and love seeing good model airports! Here are my credentials with what I’ve made/working on:

A generally finished Fictional layout:
View attachment 61355
View attachment 61353

WIP PHL:
View attachment 61354

Small Ramp Section:
View attachment 61356

Runway Section:
View attachment 61357

Can I review these? If so I’ll do them all in one. I’ll send you the form a litter later if you want to sign up more formally.

 

[bakejobb_23]

Can I review these? If so I’ll do them all in one. I’ll send you the form a litter later if you want to sign up more formally.

You can! I’d want to send in better overall photos for that.

I was meaning more in the realm of what Sithan400 was saying with a handful of critiquers with some good experience is all! I haven’t been doing it very long but i’m decently knowledgeable on realistic airport markings as well as some general craft skills for tips when it comes to grass or buildings.

 

[BubblesAviation]

You can! I’d want to send in better overall photos for that.

I was meaning more in the realm of what Sithan400 was saying with a handful of critiquers with some good experience is all! I haven’t been doing it very long but i’m decently knowledgeable on realistic airport markings as well as some general craft skills for tips when it comes to grass or buildings.

ill send you the form via dm